Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Our Properties
A light-filled Montrose living room with oak furniture and a blue throw looks onto a quiet winter backyard with dormant grasses and traces of snow.

Why Montrose Has So Many Homes for Sale This Winter

November 19, 2026

At the end of October 2026, Montrose County had 313 single-family homes for sale. That is 7.5 months of supply, according to the Colorado Association of REALTORS® Local Market Update for October 2026, and it is higher than the October figure for 2019 or for any year from 2021 through 2025. Through October of this year, fewer homes came on the market than in the same months of 2019 or 2021. What changed is the number of buyers who closed on them.

That difference shapes how you should read a Montrose listing this winter. If you're comparing Montrose with Ridgway, Ouray, or the acreage around Colona, it's worth seeing where the inventory came from before deciding what it means for price.

Seven Octobers of single-family inventory

CAR publishes a county snapshot every month. Lined up October to October, the single-family series shows a five-year climb, with this year as the steepest step.

October Single-family homes for sale Months of supply
2019 213 3.8
2021 121 1.7
2022 170 2.7
2023 188 3.8
2024 203 4.1
2025 228 4.8
2026 313 7.5

Each figure comes from that year's October report, as first published. In October 2021, a buyer in Montrose County had fewer than two months of supply to choose from. In October 2026, it's roughly four times that. Seen against 2019, the last fall before the pandemic-era rush, inventory now sits about 100 homes higher, and months of supply has nearly doubled.

A wider count that includes townhomes and condos, from the Colorado Real Estate Network's FastStats page, put October 2026 at 350 homes and 7.6 months of supply. That is up from 265 homes and 5.3 months a year earlier. The direction is the same either way you count.

Fewer buyers, not more sellers

Inventory grows when homes come on the market faster than they sell. So the useful question is which side moved. Comparing January through October across three years makes it clear.

January through October New single-family listings Single-family sales
2019 825 582
2021 836 712
2026 781 414

Sellers in Montrose County listed fewer single-family homes in the first ten months of 2026 than they did over the same stretch of 2019 or 2021. Sales dropped much harder. The 414 closed sales through October 2026 are about 42 percent below the 712 recorded through October 2021, and about 29 percent below the 582 in 2019.

Compared only with 2025, new listings through October rose 10 percent and sales fell 5.9 percent, according to this year's CAR report. So sellers did add some homes this year. Even so, the total stayed below the earlier years, and the bigger change is on the buying side.

Prices held, so the slack showed up as time

When there are fewer buyers, a market has two ways to adjust. Prices can drop until buyers come back, or homes can sit longer at roughly the same prices. Montrose has mostly done the second.

The single-family median for January through October 2026 was $472,000, against $470,000 for the same months of 2025. That's flat. It is also about 76 percent above the $268,750 median for the first ten months of 2019.

Time on the market is where the adjustment shows. Single-family homes that sold in October 2026 took an average of 134 days, compared with 66 days in October 2021 and 115 in October 2019. Sellers also gave up a little more off their asking price. For January through October 2026, they received 97.3 percent of list price, compared with 99.5 percent over the same months of 2021. On a $472,000 home, that gap is roughly $10,400. CAR notes that its list-price figure leaves out seller concessions, so any closing-cost help a seller agrees to comes on top of that.

Single-month medians are where many readers get misled. CAR's single-family count put the October 2026 median at $497,500, down 4.3 percent from a year earlier. The wider FastStats count, which includes townhomes and condos, put it at $510,000, up 10 percent. Each figure rests on about 31 or 32 sales. A month that small can swing either way depending on which few homes happened to close. Monthly counts also get revised. October 2025 was first published as 54 single-family sales with a $494,750 median, and this year's report lists that same month as 49 sales at $520,000. Inventory and days on market are the steadier readings, and both say the same thing. We made a similar point about Ouray's median price earlier this fall, where the sample is even smaller.

A year of higher mortgage rates

Many buyers stepped back during a year when borrowing got more expensive. Freddie Mac's weekly survey put the 30-year fixed rate at 7.11 percent as of November 12, 2026. A year earlier, it was 6.24 percent. The rate has come down for four weeks in a row, from 7.24 percent on October 29 and 7.18 percent on November 5, but it's still close to a full point above last fall.

To put that in dollars, we ran the standard fixed-rate amortization formula on a $400,000, 30-year loan. Principal and interest come to about $2,460 a month at 6.24 percent and about $2,690 at 7.11 percent. That's roughly $230 more every month for the same house at the same price. The reports don't prove that rates are the reason sales fell, but the timing fits. These figures are general information, not financial advice. Your own rate and payment depend on your lender and your situation, so confirm them with a loan professional.

Higher rates have touched more than for-sale homes. When the City of Montrose reviewed the Hub at Montrose Crossing this July, it reported that the developer had pointed to higher interest rates and construction costs as the reason an earlier development agreement lapsed. The Montrose Economic Development Corporation reported that construction on the 160-unit market-rate apartment project began September 15, 2026, at an estimated $53 million investment. Those are rentals, not homes for sale, so they add to rental supply rather than to the inventory in the tables above.

Where new construction is priced

New homes are the other option for a Montrose buyer, and current builder pricing sits above the resale middle. At Homes at Cobble Creek, Spruce Point patio homes of about 1,740 square feet were listed at $589,000 to $610,000 in early November. At Valley Ranch, Coker Homes showed 14 available lots priced from $125,000 to $199,000, with pricing effective November 11, 2026. Its floor plans start at $720,000 to $1,319,000, and the final price depends on lot and options.

These are asking prices, not closed sales, and CAR's monthly reports don't capture all new construction. Still, they show the comparison. A resale home near the county's $472,000 median, sitting on the market through the holidays, is competing with new patio homes priced more than $100,000 higher. That price gap is part of the case a resale seller can make, and it's part of what a buyer weighs when deciding how hard to push.

Reading a Montrose listing this winter

Single-family homes that sold in October had been on the market an average of 134 days, about four and a half months. When a house you're looking at has been listed since summer, its days-on-market count and price history tell you more than the listing photos. They show how long the seller has waited, and often whether the asking price has changed.

With prices flat and inventory high, there's usually room to negotiate on terms as well as price, such as timing, inspection repairs, or closing costs. The 97.3 percent list-price figure for the first ten months of 2026 is an average across the whole county, so any one house can land above or below it. For rural parcels outside town, water is part of the negotiation too, and our post on what the water rights line on a Montrose listing means covers what a share count does and doesn't promise.

If you own in Montrose and wonder what this means for your price, a home valuation is a good place to start. You can find more on the area on our Montrose neighborhood page.

If you're looking at a Montrose home that has been listed since summer and want a second opinion on its price, Ouray Real Estate Corporation is glad to go over recent closed sales with you. Reach out anytime. Let us guide you to your home in Colorado.

Explore

Our Recent Blog Posts

Follow Us On Instagram