A woman who had just finished brunch at the Old Firehouse in October thanked the new owner on her way out. According to the Ouray County Plaindealer, she told him, "That was the best meal I've had in this town in a long time."
The kitchen behind that brunch is Fireroot Kitchen, which now occupies the stone building at 185 N. Lena St. The Hearth, the restaurant before it, opened in 2024 as an upscale place for dinner and Sunday brunch. Fireroot is opening in the opposite order. It started with breakfast and lunch at a counter and plans to get to dinner later. Very little about the building had to change, because nearly everything it runs on was already there: the grill, the rooftop greenhouse, the patio and even the names.
Opening in the opposite order
Owner and chef Israel Castro opened Pat's Patio for breakfast and lunch in late September and didn't announce it. When the weather cooled he moved service indoors to the main dining hall. "We didn't want to do much of a promotion, we just wanted to open," Castro told the Plaindealer.
The Plaindealer's October 28 report described the setup at the time. Fireroot was running counter service from 9 a.m. to 3 p.m., Tuesday through Sunday. Castro planned to move to full table service in the following weeks and hoped to add dinner and cocktails sometime this winter. He said the phased opening was partly the result of trouble hiring enough staff.
The Hearth, by comparison, was built around the evening. The Plaindealer's August 2024 story on its opening described dinner and Sunday brunch in a room seating about 60 inside and 16 on the front patio. The sample menu included smoked trout rillette, lemon ricotta tortellini and Norwegian eggs Benedict with dry-cured salmon. Fireroot is starting where The Hearth stopped each week, with brunch, and working toward the dinner service The Hearth began with.
These days that means Dutch babies, the egg-batter pancakes baked in cast iron. The sweet version comes topped with seasonal fruit. The savory one uses blue corn flour and comes with bacon, sausage, sunny-side-up eggs and leafy greens.
The kitchen Pat O'Leary built
Castro hadn't planned to own a restaurant here. He moved to Placerville late last year expecting to keep working as a restaurant consultant. Then he saw the Old Firehouse. Before he became a chef he had wanted to be an architect, and he told the Plaindealer, "This building is truly a chef's dream come true."
The reasons he gave are all things the late Pat O'Leary put in. Castro listed a woodfire grill, a good prep kitchen, a patio and a greenhouse. The 2024 coverage describes the rest of what came with the building: a full bar, a gas-assisted wood-fired pizza oven imported from Italy, the wood-fired grill, and a 1,400-square-foot greenhouse on the roof. O'Leary based the greenhouse on one he had seen in Denver.
The greenhouse is where the staff overlap with the old restaurant. When The Hearth opened, the greenhouse was called The Harvest. It ran an aeroponic system of 44 towers, each able to hold 40 plants, which grows roots in a nutrient mist without soil. Sam Nafziger managed it. Castro hired Nafziger back as sous chef and greenhouse manager, and Nafziger plans to grow microgreens, strawberries and herbs for Fireroot's kitchen. Castro wants the menu to be 75% to 80% farm-to-table and to change with the seasons.
"The prior owner, Pat, he put in so much soul and heart and money and time and everything and we really want to honor him and we really want to do it right."
Castro said that to the Plaindealer, and the restaurant's name comes from the same idea. "Fireroot" refers to the firehouse, to Castro's interest in open-fire cooking, and to his focus on local food. "We want to create a concept that it is real food, it's not processed, everything we do we make it from scratch," he said.
Who is behind the counter
Castro started at the bottom of the industry, washing dishes at the Newport Harbor Yacht Club in Newport Beach, California. A mentor moved him out front to wait tables. He spent several years as a manager in several states before opening his first restaurant, a taco shop in Santa Fe that he says failed. "I wasn't ready," he told the Plaindealer. "I didn't know the back-of-house well enough."
After that he studied culinary arts at Le Cordon Bleu in Pasadena. He went on to help open about a dozen restaurants in Santa Fe, Las Vegas and Southern California as an executive chef and consultant. Before Ridgway, he was executive chef at La Posada in Santa Fe and a senior corporate chef for Remington Hospitality. Fireroot is the first restaurant he has owned since the taco shop. "Every concept I have done is now coming to this," he said.
A building that keeps changing jobs
The room is new to Castro, but the Old Firehouse has been repurposed several times before. Each owner added something to it, and much of that is still there:
- 1882. The stone building went up as housing for railroad workers, nine years before Ridgway incorporated.
- The following decades. It served as town hall, fire station, school and social hub.
- 1969. The original "True Grit" used it as a filming location, and the production company added the bell tower so it would look more like a late-1800s school. The belfry is still there.
- 1990s and 2000s. After it became private property in the 1980s, sculptor Michael McCullough used it as a studio. His partner, Lucy Boody, filled the empty ground around it with a changing garden of trees, shrubs, plants, hand-sculpted fairies and benches.
- 2017. Pat and Marti O'Leary bought the building and spent years remodeling it. The result was a mixed-use project of more than 16,000 square feet with a restaurant, an office, residences, and indoor and outdoor community space.
- August 2024. The Hearth opened. Pat had died that spring, so Marti finished the project with help from friends and staff. She closed the restaurant about a year later. According to the Plaindealer, the building was still in pristine condition when Castro found it.
- September 2026. Fireroot Kitchen opened on Pat's Patio.
The names from that history are still on the property. When The Hearth opened in 2024, the outdoor patio already had Pat's name. Fireroot's website lists four spaces: Pat's Patio, Lucy's Garden, the Fireroot Kitchen cocktail space and The Hearth. The Hearth is no longer the restaurant. The name now belongs to the ballroom-style celebration room.
Before you walk over
The building is at the corner of North Lena and Clinton streets, a block that most people in town pass regularly. Here is what Fireroot had posted for this fall:
- Hours. The restaurant's website lists Pat's Patio as open Tuesday through Sunday, 9 a.m. to 3 p.m., with brunch on Sundays. These match the hours the Plaindealer reported in late October.
- Service. Breakfast and lunch were counter service in late October, with full table service planned.
- Dinner and cocktails. Castro is aiming for sometime this winter. firerootkitchen.com is the place to check before planning an evening there.
- The patio. It's heated, and Castro plans to keep it open to diners all year.
- Private events. Fireroot caters and takes reservations for The Hearth banquet room and the lounge beside it. The website mentions weddings, rehearsal dinners and welcome receptions.
If you're planning a holiday gathering this winter, the most important date is when the Old Firehouse starts serving dinner, which hasn't been set. When it does, it will be cooking on the same wood-fired grill The Hearth used, with greens from the same rooftop towers.
Our office has been on Main Street in Ouray since 1971, and we like to see a building with this much Ridgway history in use again. If you own an older building in Ouray County, or are thinking about buying one, and want to talk about what it has been and what it could become, Ouray Real Estate Corporation is happy to have that conversation. Let us guide you to your home in Colorado.